Judgment Won but Still Unpaid? Payment Hearings in BC Small Claims Court Explained

Winning a judgment for an unpaid invoice in BC Small Claims Court is an important step, but it is not the same as getting paid. If the debtor does not pay after the court makes its order, the Small Claims process gives the creditor a tool called a payment hearing. This guide explains, in plain terms, what the official BC government and Provincial Court resources say about how payment hearings work.
What is a payment hearing?
A payment hearing is a court appearance that takes place after a money order has been made. According to the BC government's Small Claims Guide "Getting results", either the creditor or the debtor can ask the judge for a payment hearing. It can be requested when the order is made, and either side can come back later if the debtor does not pay as agreed or if the debtor's circumstances change.
The hearing gives the court a chance to look at the debtor's financial situation and decide how and when the debt should be paid. The Provincial Court's page on enforcing small claims orders explains that payment hearings are governed by Rule 12 of the Small Claims Rules.
How a creditor starts the process
For a creditor, the starting document is the Summons to a Payment Hearing (Form 12). The government guide describes these steps:
File the summons at the court registry, by mail or in person. The registry sets the date and time and notes how each party will attend.
Serve the debtor personally, or arrange for someone else to do it. The guide states: "Service by mail is not permitted."
The summons cannot be served outside British Columbia.
If the debtor is a company, the summons can name a director, officer or employee. For a partnership, it can name any partner.
Have a sworn affidavit of service ready in case the debtor does not appear.
If the judge is satisfied that the debtor is avoiding the court process, the guide says substituted service may be possible by court order.
What happens at the hearing
At the hearing, the creditor can ask the debtor questions about their finances. The government guide lists examples such as employment, vehicles or land owned, the bank branches where the debtor has accounts, and monthly income and expenses. The creditor can also ask the debtor to bring documents such as:
pay slips
credit card statements
the last income tax return
The guide notes that a statement of monthly income and expenses form is available from the registry and may be helpful.
What the judge can order
If the debtor needs time to pay, the judge will ask whether the creditor agrees with the debtor's proposed payment schedule. If the creditor agrees, the judge can make the order on those terms. If the creditor does not agree, the government guide says the judge may:
order a payment schedule without the creditor's consent, if the creditor is being unreasonable; or
not order any schedule, in which case the debt is due immediately.
The guide also explains an important consequence: if a payment schedule is ordered and the debtor misses a payment or pays only part, "the whole amount of the order becomes due immediately." Schedules can be changed later, and either side can ask for another payment hearing.
If the debtor does not attend or does not pay
The government guide warns debtors that they can be arrested for not attending if they were served with a summons or were ordered to attend by a judge. If a debtor falls behind on a court-ordered payment schedule, the creditor can ask for a default hearing. The guide says that if the judge finds the debtor in contempt, the debtor can be jailed for up to 20 days and still owes the money.
Other enforcement tools to know about
A payment hearing is one of several options. The same government guide also describes:
Garnishment of wages or bank accounts, under the Court Order Enforcement Act.
Seizure and sale of the debtor's goods by a court bailiff, which the guide warns can be costly.
Registering a certificate of judgment against land in the land title office.
The guide states that a judgment can be enforced for ten years. Each tool has its own forms, fees and limits, so it is worth reading the official guide carefully before choosing a path. General information about the Small Claims process and fees is also on the BC government's Small Claims page.
How HaqWise can help
HaqWise is a legal-technology app for claimants in British Columbia pursuing unpaid invoices and service-contract debts in BC Small Claims Court, for claims from $5,000 to $35,000. It helps you organize your invoices, correspondence and claim documents in one place, and the Personal plan ($339 + GST + PST) includes document review by a BC lawyer. HaqWise cannot guarantee that a debtor will pay or that a claim will succeed. HaqWise Corp. is not a law firm and does not give legal advice. You can learn more at app.haqwise.ai, call 604-771-2432, or email support@haqwise.ai.
This article is general information about British Columbia law, not legal advice.

Comments